Select Page

Dispelling Self-Publishing Myths

Dispelling Self-Publishing Myths

Recently, I was invited to sit on a panel at Scribble Festival, ‘Tips for Publishing: Traditional vs. Self-publishing’ alongside Michael Schmidt, managing director of Carcanet Press and Len Grant, professional photographer and writer. As part of their continued aim to encourage creativity and inclusivity, Cartwheel Arts co-ordinate Scribble Festival, an event designed to celebrate community writing and storytelling held at the independent bookshop, Chapter One Books. Chaired by a member of the Cartwheel Arts team, we discussed finding new voices in the community, focusing on how writers can get their work out there and how self-publishing platforms, digital media and traditional publishing methods continue to overlap in an ever-changing industry.

Attending in my capacity as a self-publishing marketing expert, I was asked the age-old question: ‘What’s the difference between publishing and self-publishing?’ It’s a question that we receive on a daily basis at Matador but upon mentioning that the primary difference was that the author has to foot the cost themselves, some writers were initially put off. They wouldn’t have the acclaim of being ‘picked up’ by a publisher if they had to pay for it themselves, surely?

This led to the perfect opportunity to debunk the myths of self-publishing. Firstly, self-publishing doesn’t mean vanity publishing. Many authors are using self-publishing as their route to market while retaining creative control of their product and ensuring their publishing journey focuses on their aims. One of the key benefits of the self-publishing industry is the level of control authors can expect from the process. While self-publishing is a massive undertaking, many authors thrive on the creativity surrounding the production of their work and others love the chance to conduct their own marketing – from visiting bookshops and festivals to contacting the media and creating a fan base on social media. Many writers, several of whom came up to me once the panel was finished, were astounded by how they could design a project suited to their needs while retaining all the rights to the book – evidently a big fear for those present, particularly upon learning that a traditional publisher could buy the rights, allowing them to negotiate future TV and film rights with minimal input from the author.

While many writers loved the idea of having control over their project, Michael at Carcanet Press questioned whether this is a good thing or not. Without the validation of the industry and the advice of seasoned experts, he reasoned, can an author be sure that they’re hitting their primary market? Authors published via traditional methods can rely on the expertise of publishing professionals to guarantee a certain level of success – after all, a publisher isn’t going to invest in a book they don’t think will sell. However, this allows for a very selective collection of books to be published each year, following trends that don’t always allow for cross-genre and niche titles. Author control doesn’t equal poor quality; more and more authors are outsourcing aspects that they don’t feel they can do themselves (for example cover design) to create books of a similar, if not the same, quality to that of mainstream publications. Additionally, it allows authors the opportunity to do their own research on sites like The Self-Publishing Magazine, investigating what works well for their genre, what doesn’t and what they want to get out of the project – as well as a whole raft of things in between. Publishing traditionally isn’t the only way to publish in an informed way.

Many of the writers at Scribble Festival are involved in community outreach projects working with marginalised members of society, from immigrants to victims of domestic abuse, and therefore it’s unlikely the types of stories they want to publish will be featuring on the radars of mainstream publishers. For these writers, publishing would not be their route to landing a Pulitzer Prize, but rather a means of sharing their stories and personal journeys, something that has become much more accessible following the rise of self-publishing.

Everyone at Scribble Festival had a different story to tell, with different aims, and wished to do it in a different way. For me, it was fascinating to discuss all aspects of publishing with those that are passionate about their projects; it allowed each of us the opportunity to share our experience and knowledge with like-minded individuals who had perhaps never considered self-publishing as an option.

About The Author

Alice is the Assistant Marketing Manager at Troubador Publishing. For two years, she has been marketing books published under their high-quality self-publishing imprint, Matador, which involves working closely with authors, the book trade and the media. She regularly represents Troubador at events in her capacity as a self-publishing expert. Alice studied English Language and Linguistics at the University of Sheffield. In her spare time, she runs and practises yoga, as well as relaxing with a gritty thriller while on route to far flung destinations.

Video Update!

From the editor…

Events season is here. Perhaps you're heading to the Self-Publishing Conference this spring? Literary events are great opportunities for authors to network and learn more about the competition, and the market as a whole.

If you’ve completed our survey already then thank you; we’re taking your comments and opinions on board. If not, please spare a minute or two to fill it in (link below). We love hearing from you and want to know how we can change our site so that it best meets your needs.


We have a packed content schedule lined up throughout spring. Keep an eye out for more in our ‘Back to Basics’ series and some guest posts about interesting industry developments – as well as lots of tips and tricks about writing and indie publishing.

We would love your feedback

We would love to hear your thoughts about our website.

Please fill in our survey by clicking here; your feedback is greatly appreciated.

Indie Pick


The first in a series of stories about life in a rural England coping with the challenges of the Agricultural Revolution

Tom Norbery’s decision to bring two orphaned children to live at Linmore Hall, changes the life of his son for the better. It does not make his older brother less aggressive, or his mother kinder, but for the first time in his life, Joshua has a friend – someone to talk to, to share his adventures and ambitions with. All he has to do is accept Charlie Cobarne’s little sister as part of the package, which does not seem much to ask.

But Sophie disdains female refinements in favour of masculine hunting pursuits at which she excels. She challenges her brother and Joshua and in so doing, she binds their friendship together… but her continuing presence causes the once strong bond between the young men to become a recipe for misunderstandings.

Changing circumstances force Sophie to conceive a plan. Single minded in her determination to keep them together, Sophie little realises the far-reaching potential consequences if her plans should go awry. Who has the most to lose?

Recent Tweets